Brotherhood - The Complete Second Season

Posted in: Disc Reviews by Gino Sassani on October 17th, 2008

Overall

Film

Video

Audio

Extras

Buy at Amazon.com

Released Tuesday, October 7, 2008

1.78:1 Widescreen
Box Set
DVD
Disc Reviews
Dolby Digital 5.1 (English)
Drama
Showtime
Television

I think it’s safe to say that HBO changed the face of television with the arrival of The Sopranos back in 1999. The show raised the bar for television across the board. Before we knew it, many of the cable networks were scrambling to offer up the next show that would generate the same praise from critics and audiences alike. To this day that show has generated more subscribers to a pay network than any other. So, we really can’t blame the network’s rival Showtime for trying to have their own Sopranos. And that’s exactly what The Brotherhood is.

The focus of this crime drama centers on two brothers. It’s the classic sibling rivalry story. It’s Caine and Abel; it’s Jacob and Esau. Michael (Isaacs) is the criminal brother and the eldest. In the first season we have Michael returning to Providence after fleeing a hit contract years before. The motivation for Michael is that he wants to regain his power hold on his former territory. Younger brother Tommy (Clarke) has taken a far different path in life. Overcoming his family’s ties to crime, he has become a Rhode Island congressman. Far from a “good guy”, Tommy has his own demons. His marriage to Eileen (Gish) is falling apart, but they continue to put up the expected front for his ambitious political dreams. There is a rather clever moral twist on the two brothers. It is Michael who has the traditional family values, willing to make sacrifices for his family, while it’s Tommy who neglects his family for his own political ends. Now it’s his own wife who is having an affair and has become addicted to drugs, something that can fatally harm his re-election bid. The boys have a mom (Flanagan) that would shame even Livia Soprano. She’s manipulated both brothers toward her own definition of family. Finally there’s sister Mary Kate (O’Malley). Outside of the immediate family is their main nemesis, State Trooper Giggs (Embry). You get the impression they were all real tight as youths, but now Giggs wants to get the legal drop on the entire Caffee family. Talk about bitter. This guy has a ton of baggage, from his own marriage break-up to disgrace on the force. He appears to see the Caffee boys as his ticket to redemption.

I will tell you as someone who tried that you simply can’t begin your experience with this series in season 2. There are so many characters and plot threads that the writers assume you’ve caught up on that it will leave you unable to settle in. The first year appears to have ended with a hit attempt on Michael. Obviously he survives, but it seems it was somewhat of a cliffhanger. Fortunately the first episode provided a neat little recap of the first season, but all in all I was left feeling like everyone understood but me. The series is absolutely worth your time, however. The writing is rather clever, and the production values are high. Mostly you’ll fall into the trap of actually caring for these characters, which owes a lot to some provocative performances from the entire cast. It’s violent, to be sure, but no more so than The Sopranos was. It’s a grittier, less Hollywood style of storytelling, and as the warning admonishes: For Mature Audiences Only. This is not one for the kiddies.

Video

Each Episode of Brotherhood is presented in its original 1.78:1 aspect ratio. I never saw the Showtime broadcasts, but I assume this transfer is comparable. Black levels are solid, which is great because there is a decidedly dark tone to even daylight scenes. Colors and flesh tones also share that darker tone, but the image stays crisp and sharp throughout.

Audio

The Dolby Digital 5.1 track is not really anything to write home about. This is a very dialog heavy presentation, so you can expect everything to be front loaded here. It’s all clean and clear, but I found the overall lack of dynamic range here to be a little disappointing. There are gunfights and such, and they appear to be rather dull in the audio department.

Special Features

Nothing

Final Thoughts

I’ve heard it said that this is basically an Irish version of The Sopranos, but that would be an oversimplification and frankly unfair to The Brotherhood. The similarities certainly can’t be ignored, but this show has a decidedly different feel to it overall. The brother angle, not surprisingly considering the title, is far more what this series is about. If you liked The Sopranos, you will be inclined to like this show, but I give you two warnings. First, start from the beginning. Do yourself a favor I was not in a position to do. Make sure you’re up to speed by the time you watch these second season episodes. Second, don’t go in with the expectation that you’re watching the HBO show. They are not the same, and you will color your perceptions unnecessarily to the point that you won’t give these characters the opportunity to tell their own unique story. Otherwise you’ll end up feeling like “a stranger who wandered in at four minutes to midnight”.