• Forum
  • Elementary: The Fifth Season

    Posted in: Disc Reviews by Gino Sassani on August 31st, 2017

    (out of 5)

    “My name is Sherlock, and I’m an addict.”

    Elementary is one of those shows that rather quietly continues to do what it does without drawing a ton of attention, but yet enough fans that the series has been able to reach the 100-episode milestone here in its fifth season. That used to be a little more important than it is today. Years ago a show’s only chance at making money after the original run was through syndication. Today there are less independent stations, and they tend toward the situation comedies more than drama. There are cable networks that once used these shows as their primary material. Remember when TNT might as well have been called The Law & Order Network. But even those times are drying up. Cable networks are churning out more and more of their own scripted shows so that there is less and less space for syndication. Today shows live on in the form of streaming services like Netflix or home video like the latest CBS release of Elementary The Complete 5th Season. 100 episodes continues to be impressive, and it appears there are legs left for more to come.

    Jonny Lee Miller’s portrayal of Holmes makes me want to start drawing comparisons to the title character in the medical drama House. Both shows surround an eccentric, drug-addicted savant who blazes beyond socially acceptable behavior to a series of “aha!” moments. Granted, said “aha!” moments are much less contrived and formulaic than they are in House. It takes a little while for the show to get its legs, but it does. The creators are clearly hoping the eccentric charm of Holmes can shoulder the burden of maintaining audience interest. Said eccentricity can come off a bit aimless at first. Sherlock has the ability examine people almost perfectly, yet the writers do not seem to have the character fully figured out, and there are too many moments where Holmes’ odd behavior seems a bit tacked on, such as when he hypnotizes himself to get through an addiction support group meeting.

    Each episode features a mildly captivating crime puzzle for Holmes to solve. Lucy Liu plays Watson. This incarnation of the classic character is a disgraced former surgeon who is assigned to keep Holmes from falling back into his heroin addiction. Very soon she begins assisting him in his investigations as she demonstrates a great aptitude for it. The platonic chemistry between Holmes and Watson is a bit of an issue for this show. Watson is more babysitter than partner, but they do start to grow closer as the series progresses. There is no real hint of romantic connection between them, which I enjoy. This show avoids the laziest possible device for character tension, and I applaud it for that. For you non-bookworms out there, Holmes’ drug use is actually taken from the original stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. There are numerous references to Holmes’ use of various drugs and stimulants, many coming from Watson’s perspective, which means that this adaptations method of having Watson be a caretaker of Holmes is more closely related to the original than one might assume.

    There are some interesting developments in Season 5. The first is the change of Holmes’ look. He shaves his head. I’m not so sure I like it. It makes him look a little sickly. I guess we’ll see how that plays out by next season. He’s also getting closer to Watson. This season marks a rather dramatic admission from Holmes that the joy of the cases is no longer the solving but rather the solving together. For a guy with this kind of ego, that’s a huge step in personal development. Holmes also deals with the arrival of his former London investigations partner Kitty Winter, who has found a connection between cases they worked and a string of murders.

    Watson also has some personal revelations. When a former patient whose life she saved enters the picture, she thinks she can save him again. He was tricked into killing his best friend and wants to get out of the life. He’s a good guy with good intentions, but we’ve all heard about that roadway project to Hell and the materials used. She also must deal with a DEA investigation when her doctor ID is stolen and thousands of illegal prescriptions are written in her name.

    The other characters get to shine as well. Bell has new romantic interest, but it comes complete with an angry ex-husband who is trying to make big trouble for the detective. The conflict gets us behind the character’s curtain, and we learn quite a lot about his history. He had an abusive father who abused both him and his mother. This violent guy brings a lot of memories crashing down. It’s really a breakout season for Detective Bell and particularly for actor Jon Michael Hill.

    Holmes plays matchmaker for Captain Gregson. He wants him to marry a woman who has a terminal disease but no health insurance. This way she can get the help she needs. Meanwhile actor Aidan Quinn gets to direct an episode of the show this season. The season ends with Holmes experiencing some strange mental issues, and it promises to lead into another unique situation for him in Season 6.

    Other cases involve pirate’s treasure, video games, clown murders, poisoned sausage, and snake venom. You get all 24 episodes on six DVD’s. Extras include a feature on the 100th episode celebration, gag reel, feature on the show’s writing, and the usual CBS half-hour season summary. It’s out right now. “I’m happy to give you the rundown.”

    Posted In: No Huddle Reviews

    Leave a Reply

    CSS Template by RamblingSoul | Tomodachi theme by Theme Lab