“I know who the Ice Cream Man is. He drove a truck, and no one knew his name or his past. He spoke with a foreign accent, so we figured he came from someplace war-torn. All he wanted to do is make children happy with his ice cream. He was blamed for the crimes of another. Horrible, unspeakable crimes. The scandal was too great. Rumors spread in a small town. Something had to be done. It was decided to put the blame on someone disposable. One lawyer went after him. He made all the kids lie in court. All of the children testified against the Ice Cream Man. The adults fed them lies, and they regurgitated these lies on the stand.”
The first thing you need to know is that Eli Roth’s Ice cream Man is in no way related to the 1995 film of the same name starring Clint Howard. In that film the kids become a part of the ice cream in a kind of Soylent Green situation. This film had been gestating in Eli Roth’s head for decades. He took the idea to studios, but no one was willing to touch it. Now after having a reputation and several hit films under his belt, Roth has opened up his own production company called The Horror Section. Ice Cream Man became the first film to be produced by the new company. It’s now out on video with the Mill Creek/Alliance Entertainment release of Ice Cream Man on UHD Blu-ray in 4K.
“When he was in jail, someone came to visit him. He said he was a lawyer, but everything out of his mouth was a lie except for one promise, that he would help the Ice Cream Man get his revenge on the town. He was a necromancer, someone who raises the dead for a price. The Ice Cream Man’s soul in exchange for his revenge. The Necromancer promised that would bring him back with special powers once the kids had grown into adults. The next day they found him dead in his cell. They decided to bury him in an unmarked grave by the sap of the river.”
The plot here is dreadfully simple. We open during a typical spring day in Bayleen Bay. It’s your perfect American town. Kids playing baseball, where we meet Jared, played by Charlie Zeltzer. He’s an awkward young boy, and his error costs his team the game. Obviously, he’s not a popular kid, and he’s mostly picked on by all the other kids. But something other than bullies has entered this suburban town. There’s an ice cream truck, and it’s doling out treats to all of the children in the town. The names of the treats are a bit odd, and maybe that’s where we should get our first inkling that this is no ordinary ice cream truck. And this was no ordinary ice cream man. Flavors like Web Of Fudge, Froggy’s Swamp Pop, and Locust Lick adorn the truck’s colorful poster. The treats are represented by pictures of spiders, frogs, scorpions, and snakes. Most of the kids enjoy the treats, but Jared can’t because on top of his awkwardness, he’s lactose intolerant. At home we find an ordinary American family. He has an older sister, Lizzie (Abbott) and parents played by Eli Roth himself and Karen Cliche. All appears normal until late that night. When everyone’s asleep, the Ice Cream Man returns and plays his silly jingle. It acts as some kind of activator, and all of the kids who had ice cream that day awaken and begin to kill all the adults they can find. It starts with their parents but moves out in the morning to the school and streets. These are all elaborate blood kills that include a girl sawing off her mother’s head, which she then carries with her like a doll. There’s a lot of body parts being removed, and likely more blood than Eli Roth has ever shed on screen before. And this is the guy who brought us the Hostel films, which pretty much started the torture porn genre.
When Jared wakes, it’s like he’s in a Twilight Zone episode. Mobs of gleeful children with cute little ice cream and sprinkles smudged on their faces are out there dismantling every one they can find. There are a few kids who did not have the ice cream, and they kind of band together to help each other survive and try to find a way to stop the madness. Mia (Waldman) is the pretty girl who wouldn’t give Jordan the time of day but is a bit humbled now. Tommy (O’Reilly) is another kid Jared never was able to be friends with in ordinary days. Most of the film these three are trying to stay one step ahead of the killing spree. Jared’s sister Lizzie ate the ice cream, but because she was a teen it didn’t turn her into a monster. She does have trouble moving her arms. Then there’s her idiot boyfriend (Chris Hawco) whose only contribution is his pickup truck. All of the adults are being slaughtered in a mass of blood and guts. Kids play with the body parts. They play tag with a severed hand and tetherball with someone’s head. When first responders arrive, they get slaughtered as well.
They find an old priest (Davis) when they hide in a freezer. He tells them the tale and tells them how to kill the guy and release the children. It’s not so easy, and the film ends in kind of a mess.
“Ringa ding ding. Ringa ding dong. Ringa ding ding it’s the ice cream song.”
OK, that jingle will drive you crazier than these kids. Roth is pretty much doing Roth things here, and he’s basically telling the story of The Pied Piper, of course. It’s all as simple as that. The problem is there are so many slaughter scenes and so much gore for so long that you kind of get numb to it, and it’s no longer very effective. This is why slaughter films have those slower tension scenes between kills. If all you have is wall-to-wall kills, after an hour it really doesn’t matter anymore. The problem is that Roth does quite well when he’s telling the Pied Piper story, but when he’s on his own for an ending, everything really falls apart. It loses its momentum and crashes before he’s able to bring this one in for a nice landing. There is certainly a point when too much isn’t just better. Roth crossed that line here.
I have to give credit to Ari Millen, who plays The Ice Cream Man. He never says a word the entire film. He just gives you these creepy smile looks that I have to admit really reache you in that unguarded back of your brain where you’re being told “There’s something really wrong and dangerous here.” The kids are pretty convincing, as well. They’re likely having the time of their lives on this set, and it pretty much shows. If only he could have kept the magic going until the final credits.
The Steelbook Edition comes with a UHD Blu-ray and a regular Blu-ray with a ton of interviews. They were unsettling. For some reason they were all very oddly cut. In the middle of a sentence there’s a jarring cut, and I have to tell you it seems like a nitpick, but it’s not. It’s like watching a glitchy disc and just becomes unwatchable, plus with so much editing the people appear manic and never take a breath. It makes you find them untrustworthy, because I was distracted by thoughts of “So what got cut out there?” You get some photo cards and stickers for the ice cream flavors that are scented, which I thought was a clever thing to include. It’s one of those films to watch and just forget. It’s entertaining enough for that. “That’s not good, either, but at least it’s positive.”

