“Are you ready?”
I’m not sure that I am. Dutton Ranch is likely the more anticipated of the Yellowstone spinoff shows that were revealed as Yellowstone was winding down. We’ve already seen a full season of Marshals, and that’s been really good. Dutton Ranch, however, is much more of a mixed bag. While Taylor Sheridan didn’t exactly create the show, it still beas his mark, and he is the top-listed executive producer. You see, this one is a bit of a good news/bad news bargain for me. It includes my favorite character from Yellowstone along with my least favorite character, and, unfortunately, they are not separable. What’s not to love about Cole Hauser playing Rip? He’s a cowboy’s cowboy. He’s tougher than Daddy Dutton ever was, and he’s about the most authentic thing about the franchise, and that’s saying something. But then there’s Beth. God, that character as annoyed me since the original show’s first episode. There’s nothing likable here, and it’s that rare Sheridan performance that just doesn’t feel right to me. The one thing he does better than almost anyone else is create characters and cast the perfect performer to play them. He’s got a 99% hit record there as far as I’m concerned, but Beth and Kelly Reilly is like nails on a chalkboard. In fact, give me the nails every time. Look, I don’t know who is at fault here. I’m not saying Reilly is bad. I really haven’t seen her in much else, and I’m sure she got this gig for a reason, but I really hate this character a lot. I should correct myself. She USED to be my least favorite character in the franchise. More on that later.
“The best part of working is stoppin.'”
When we left these characters, they were living in a cabin on a piece of the Yellowstone that Dad left them as a wedding present. They were doing pretty well. They were settled and ran the place carefree. One night a wildfire comes tearing through and destroys it all. The cattle, the house, and their stuff are all gone in a matter of seconds. They save a couple of horses and some important documents, but it’s all gone in a flash. Jump six months later, and they are now in the small Texas town of Rio Paloma. It’s a small town where everyone knows everyone else’s business. As soon as they are there, the three members of the family have bad encounters with the ruling family, the Jacksons. They are the Dutton icons here. The ranch is 190 years old, and the family matriarch, Beulah, played by Annette Bening, fights for it as hard as Costner’s character did for Yellowstone. And our three waste no time meeting them.
Rip has a run-in with one of two “not really” brothers. The sons of Beulah. He’s Rob-Will, played by Jai Courtney. He’s high. He’s drunk. He’s a killer, and we learn that early. He makes the mistake of pulling a gun on Rip. Obviously, we know that didn’t go well. Mom tries to send him to rehab just to keep him out of trouble, but we know he’ll be back.
Carter, played by Finn Little, is the adopted son of Rip and Beth. He’s 19 and behind in school and isn’t happy having to go. But he runs into Oreana Jackson, played by Natalie Alyn Lind. She’s hot and entitled. She’s the daughter of Rob Will. Carter comes to her aid when a boyfriend smacks her in a parking lot. Now he’s also in trouble with the town sheriff, Handy Wade, played by Josh Stewart. He likes the kid and tries to cut him a break, but they will have several run-ins before the nine episodes are over. Carter is now the big problem. Finn Little and his character here actually annoy me worse than Beth ever did. He is the weakest link on this show, and it’s not even close. The character just doesn’t really make any sense at all. I expect it’s the writing, because I never really had an issue with the character or actor before. But he makes Beth a bit of a whiff of fresh air. He has this odd relationship with Oreana, who is a cardboard cutout of the daughter on Landman. I mean, they could be the same person. She’s oversexed and manipulative. How about a little fresher group of characters here?
Beth has her encounter with Momma. Momma won’t take her slaughter business because she’s too small. Beth spends a lot of her time and talents finding a workaround and cutting off the competition at the meat table. But in a flash the ranch suffers another complete loss, and all of those first season things are pretty much dead-end threads. Before it’s over, Rip and Beth have somehow cut themselves into the Jackson Ranch and get her agree to let them run it. Of course, both parties have ulterior motives, and they’re the same. They both want to dig up dirt on each other. This part might actually be fun in the future, but just when things were finally getting going, we get thrown a complete blindside involving a drug cartel. Didn’t we just see this on both Tulsa King and Landman? There’s a lot of recycling going on here, and I don’t think it’s about saving the planet.
Now there are two exceptional additions to our cast here. How can you not love Ed Harris as the local vet and former lover to Beulah, Everett “Edward” McKinney? Even pushing his eighties, Harris is a strong presence everywhere he goes, and this is no exception. The whole dang mess is worth watching just for his compelling performance. There’s also the “other” brother who, like Carter is adopted: Joaquin, played by Juan Pablo Raba. He’s a great counter to Rip. They are more alike than either would ever admit, but their encounters are also compelling television. There’s Dutton Ranch hand Azul, played by J.R. Villarreal, and he’s the character that really grounds us here. Finally we have Zach Moss, played by Marc Menchaca. He’s the colorful character here who mixes things up a bit. He’s an older guy who has been in prison and has had a pretty hard life. He’s given up the booze and found Jesus, and Rip takes a chance on him, and it’s to the benefit of the show.
The Texas setting is typical for Sheridan, but he’s not writing or directing this stuff, and we seem to be getting what appears to be a forced setting on us. It doesn’t fit on this show, but it’s forced to the front almost every minute. I could be wrong, but I’m not sure if this series is sustainable. When the next Sheridan culling comes, I vote this one off the island. But there are good characters here, and this series can still pull itself out if it focuses on what makes it compelling and good and pulleds back on what doesn’t. It doesn’t need an entire retooling here. There’s a world of potential as big as Texas, so I’ll be looking for that second season to see if they can turn this around. I’m actually rooting for them, just because I have gotten attached to some of these characters. Chad Feehan is the actual creator, but maybe it’s time for Sheridan to take a more active interest in this. The man does know how to deal with characters. “Good people don’t lose all of their good.”

