“The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.”
Every Star Trek fan has had that phrase beaten into their brain about as many times as Uncle Ben’s mantra about great power and great responsibility. Who knew that the tagline was appropriate to filmmaking? When J.J. Abrams signed on to direct the reboot/remake/reimagining/rehash (insert your own word here) of Star Trek he quickly made it known that he was not really that into the franchise. He considered himself a Star Wars man, and a chill went through the spine of every Trek fan on the planet. I approached the 2009 effort with dread.
Harry Truman had a sign at his White House desk that read: “The buck stops here”. I can well imagine Abrams with one that repeats the whole needs-of-the-many idea. It starts with the realization that Star Trek fans are in the minority, for the most part, when you count all movie audiences. It’s a strong following, to be sure, but hardly mainstream. For decades that worked as a model for releasing the films. The budgets were kept modest, and the studio could always count on the box office coming out a little ahead at the end of the day. They didn’t need to be huge, but they were never going to lose money that way. Most Trek fans always believed that if the masses would just give it a chance, they’d get it and join the parade. Still, the masses have been relatively indifferent to Star Trek. Everyone knows the iconic elements; they just didn’t really go out and spend their money to see the films. Maybe they’re afraid of the rabid convention crowds in their Starfleet uniforms or alien body parts. Perhaps it just seems to “geeky”. Whatever the reasons, they stayed away. Deep inside we still believed we could win them over. That’s where Abrams comes in.
There was another roadblock standing in Abrams’ way. Star Trek has become burdened under its own weight. We’re talking 10 movies, 28 seasons of television, over 500 novels and comic books, and tons of fan fiction and private productions. Add to that the fact that Trek fans take their continuity very seriously, and Houston, we really have a problem. It was becoming impossible to tell a story to fit all of that mythology and remain faithful enough to avoid the wrath of the fans. So Abrams did the only logical thing he could do. He literally blew up all of that Star Trek canon with a clever story that basically re-set the Trek universe with a fresh starfield of possibilities. He then sacrificed the needs of the few (fanboys) to serve the needs of the many (masses) and took his movie where no Star Trek has gone before: summer blockbuster status!
Now it’s been four years, and the follow-up film has finally arrived. The rumors were rampant, and I won’t address them at all here. Chances are you know the spoilers, if you want to know them, already. I won’t chance ruining it for the few that have avoided any information on the film. I will tell you that Abrams has managed to weave a touching love letter to the Trek faithful into what again is a hugely mainstream film that should kick some serious butt at the box office once again. It’s almost as if he wanted to thank the fans who did finally climb aboard his Enterprise. There’s a tribble, and you’ll find a model of the NX-01 Enterprise, among others. The writers pay tribute to some of Trek’s best phrases. Of course, McCoy’s going to deliver one of his “I’m a doctor not a…” lines. Scotty’s going to be called a miracle worker. And the film ends with the beginning of the crew’s five-year mission. This film is just as good at appealing to the masses, but it manages to bring the faithful in with enough nods and references to bring tearful smiles to our faces. There’s a lot of love here. Maybe it didn’t come from Abrams at all. Credit it to writers Roberto Orci, Alex Kurtzman, and to a lesser degree Damon Lindelof. They are confirmed Trek fans, and it shows.
“You think you’re safe. You are not. Is there anything you would not do for your family?”
The Star Trek family is gathered once again. Kirk (Pine) and crew are in the middle of a mission gone wrong as the film opens. Kirk and McCoy (Urban) are running for their lives on an alien planet as Spock (Quinto) is setting of a device to save the primitive planet from destruction. That pesky prime directive is in the way, and Kirk is called on the Starfleet carpet for his actions. He’s about to lose his command to Christopher Pike (Greenwood) when Starfleet succumbs to a terrorist attack at a secret spy station in London called Section 31. The man responsible is one of their own, a man named Harrison (Cumberbatch). Kirk appeals to Admiral Marcus (Weller) to pursue the villain into Klingon space. He’s given the go-ahead and 72 special new photon torpedoes to take the guy out. Marcus isn’t looking for a trial. This is all-out Bin Laden-style find-and-kill-with-prejudice time. Kirk’s fine with the idea, but it presents a moral dilemma for many in the crew. Bringing Harrison back alive is going to be problematic, particularly when many players aren’t who they appear to be. Kirk can’t tell the good guys from the bad guys and has to fly on instinct, a process his Vulcan science officer doesn’t quite get. By the end of the film the two come to a greater understanding of each other, and we see just a flash of the relationship yet to come.
One of the reasons for Star Trek’s longevity is that it’s never the same kind of story, or at least it doesn’t have to be. In Star Trek you can tell a courtroom story one time and an action thriller the next. You can tell a western or a buddy-cop story. The canvas is blank, and you don’t have to be bound one single framework. That’s what makes this film even better than the last. Abrams delivers many kinds of films rolled into one. There is a Die Hard scene where Kirk is battling a futuristic helicopter. The opening scene looks like something out of Avatar. There’s political intrigue. There’s even a scene straight out of Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid.
Abrams delivers his Star Wars audition reel here, as well. There’s a space chase/fight that looks right out of the Death Star battle. Remember the Millennium Falcon’s sweet sideways escape through the closing doors? It’s here with a shuttle that’s saucer-shaped enough to even look like The Falcon at chase speed.
The movement from one kind of set piece to another makes this film’s over two hour running time feel amazingly short. There’s as much thrilling action here as you’ll find in any superhero/comic movie this summer. Star Trek has never been this intense. I haven’t seen this much non-stop action before in a Star Trek film or episode. It’s the ride of the summer so far, even besting Iron Man 3. The special effects take the franchise to a level you have not seen before. This is groundbreaking stuff here. The space battles top even the Borg entanglements from Next Generation highpoints.. The Enterprise takes one hell of a beating in action sequences that owe more to the old World War II dogfight movies than science fiction. Abrams sound design even sneaks in some sound effects that are very much reminiscent of a fighter plane’s machine guns. This is the most rapid-fire action you can imagine. There’s plenty of old fashioned fighting to be found, as well. Spock gets himself in a thrilling brawl with Harrison as they jump from flying cargo carrier to another. Sure, it stretches credibility in enough places, but never enough to have you rolling your eyes.
That doesn’t mean the film sacrifices character and story for all of this nail-biting action. With one film under their belts, the actors have really warmed up to their parts. The Spock/Kirk relationship evolves throughout the film from one of distrust to the gut-wrenching moments of a reworked Wrath Of Kahn moment that recalls Spock’s death in that 1982 fan favorite. The chemistry between Pine and Quinto has developed into something special. Sure, it’s too early to compare it to the Shatner/Nimoy relationship, but you can absolutely see genesis of that kind of understanding. Chris Pine gets to really be James Kirk here. He even gets himself some tail, literally. Karl Urban continues to channel the spirit of DeForest Kelley as he remains the most faithful to the original performance. Zoe Saldana continues to be underused as Uhura. She’s relegated to some emotional scenes with Spock and spends too much of the film pouting and angry. John Cho’s Sulu has truly evolved, and you are seeing the beginnings of a future command officer here. Anton Yelchin continues to butcher the Russian accent here and likely gets the least amount of time to evolve Chekov. The real downer is that, like the first film, Simon Pegg has reduced Scotty to the comic relief. It’s a shame, because there’s truly wonderful humor in these characters and their relationships and reactions so that a designated comic part is totally unnecessary.
Good movies rely not only on great heroes but equally great villains. Benedict Cumberbatch has already shown great skills in his BBC Sherlock Holmes role. Here he gets to show his chops as one of Trekdom’s better bad guys. He the kind of character who can kill with a look. He’s a man with tremendous control over those around him. He’s used to being in charge. Cumberbatch portrays it all with minimalistic movement and speech. It’s the perfect example of less is more if you make the most out of the less. Like many Trek baddies before him, he’s almost Shakespearean. Peter Weller adds to the mix with a man totally comfortable with his own sense of morality and patriotism. He’s a fanatic who doesn’t see himself as anything more than a pragmatist. It’s the most dangerous kind of villain there is, isn’t it?
I saw the film in 3D, and this is one of the best uses of 3D you’ll find. The style takes us right up to the gimmick threshold and never crosses the line. I literally ducked an arrow in the opening scene. The Enterprise eats up the scenery in 3D and has never looked so real. This is one of those films where I went home having experienced something, not merely been a witness. But we are witness to something very special. Star Trek has found the place we fans always believed it could. This is a crowd pleaser throughout and you do not have to be a Star Trek person to get it. If you are, all the better, of course. The end credits are worth sitting through. There is no extra footage there, but the Alexander Courage theme is, as are some very sweet 3D effects.
This will likely be Abrams’ final journey on the Enterprise. His life is going to be dominated with the Star Wars universe for a long time to come. If Paramount wants this all to continue, and they will, someone else will have to take the reins once again. I can’t say I’ll miss Abrams’ camera flairs at all. I suspect in Star Wars you’ll have a hard time seeing those light sabers with the camera flairs all about. But I will miss his touch. In any case, he’s left his mark on our Trek universe that will not soon be erased. Roddenberry always wanted us to have hope because I just saw the best movie of the summer, so far. “Have I got your attention now?”
05/16/2013 @ 7:51 pm
I disagree with you on Uhura, Sulu, Scotty and Chekov. Uhura is a lot more fleshed out than she ever was in TOS and so what if there is romance between her and Spock? I enjoyed Scotty’s bigger role in this film and I thought Chekov was awesome, i just wish we would have seen more of him. Sulu was just okay, he didn’t add anything to the movie for me.
05/16/2013 @ 9:11 pm
Hey Chrysalis, I was comparing the evolution of the characters to the last film, not the show. I just thought this Uhura walked around ticked off most of the time.
Thanks for the input 🙂