Sometimes a movie comes along that simply has so much to say that two hours simply isn’t enough to flesh it out to its full potential. Broken City is a film that is filled with many great characters and story threads that needed more than just the 109-minute running time to tie everything all together. Broken City is more than just a film about a private eye trying to take down a corrupt mayor. Every character involved has something to gain from winning an upcoming election and even more to lose depending on the results. The same can be said about any election.
The film opens up with Billy Taggart (Mark Wahlberg) standing over the body of a suspect he’s shot down. Though the charges are dropped, Taggart is asked to leave the force; this is a decision not taken lightly, but Mayor Hostetler (Russell Crowe) insists the resignation needs to happen for the city and that he’ll be in debt to Taggart. Jumping ahead seven years, Taggart is now a private eye and is in debt. Financially, things are not looking good for Billy until he gets a call from the mayor’s office.
Hostetler views himself as a savior to the city; sure, he’s probably done many great things for New York, but from the very beginning we have reason to doubt his actions. With the election only days away he asks Taggart to follow his wife, Cathleen (Catherine Zeta-Jones) and discover who she is sleeping with and when Billy gets “the proof” Hostetler needs he’ll receive the second half of his $50,000 payment.
Taggart and his spitfire assistant Katy (Alona Tal) waste no time and start tailing the mayor’s wife. The interactions between Billy and Katy are some of the film’s lighter moments, and over the course of the film I started to wonder if there was more to these two. The chemistry between Billy and Katy was something I wish could have been explored more, but the film has its own direction and continues to charge forward. When Taggart discovers the identity of the man Cathleen is seeing, the information is almost too good to be true. The identity to the man is none other than Paul Chambers, the campaign manager to the rival candidate.
Everything appears to be open and shut, but this is only just the beginning for Taggart as he finds himself involved with a murder that he feels he is responsible for. The police commissioner Fairbanks, (Jeffrey Wright) seems to be friends with both of the candidates. Is he playing it safe, or does he have an agenda of his own? When Fairbanks discovers Taggart at the crime scene, he can’t help but wonder about the possibility of the mayor being involved.
And it’s from here I have to be careful what I write so as to not spoil any more. This is a film that answers questions, but the answers only to lead to more questions. Not only is there the affair and murder driving the plot, but there is also a large real estate scandal going on revolving around the city buying up land and evicting people for 4 billion dollars. It’s this element of the plot that had me thinking this was simply an east coast version of Chinatown. Filled with double crosses, there is a lot to enjoy with this film that in many ways is a throwback to the old noir days; granted, Wahlberg is no Bogart, but he still has his own charm.
I haven’t even gotten into the role of the rival candidate Jack Valliant (Berry Pepper), the young candidate who comes from big money but seems to be a good man and above all the corruption. But this is a film that doesn’t quite let you know the truth till it’s ready to give you a peek at it.
Director Allen Hughes, one half of the Hughes brothers that brought us Menace 2 Society and From Hell, stepped up and delivered a solid film here. With so much going on with the plot and so many diverse characters throughout, this easily could have turned into a mess. My biggest complaint remains that I wish more time was put into fleshing out these characters and the side stories more, or simply eliminate certain plot threads. Over all though Broken City delivers a nice modern noir tale that kept me entertained throughout.