Posted in: Disc Reviews by David Annandale on March 8th, 2008
Jack Lemmon is a rather meek insurance company employee who is slowly working his way up the corporate ladder by lending his apartment to married executives looking for a place to take their girlfriends. Life is rather inconvenient, as he is locked out of his home at all hours, but things become even more complicated when the big boss (Fred McMurray) takes an interest. The good news is that Lemmon gets another promotion. The bad news is that McMurray’s affair is with Shirley MacLaine, the elevator girl for whom Lemmon is carrying a torch.
Billy Wilder’s follow-up to Some Like It Hot certainly has plenty of funny moments, most involving Lemmon’s doctor neighbour (Jack Kuschen). But the film doesn’t shy away from the darker implications of its storyline (up to and including a suicide attempt). The result is a romantic comedy-drama that is sweet without being sentimental, and hard-nosed without being cynical. And the audience’s emotions are thus sincerely earned.
The sound choices are the original mono and a 5.1 remix. The latter has some warts, mainly in the form of some inappropriate sound effect placement (one example being a moment where Lemmon is unwrapping a TV dinner, and the sound of crinkling foil suddenly reverberates from all sides). The dialogue, fortunately, avoids that problem, and there are some decent environmental effects (usually in the crowded office scenes).
The print is utterly marvellous, for all intents and purposes free of grain, and there isn’t a blemish in sight. The black-and-white tones are perfect, their high contrast establishing the film’s tone as existing in that tricky realm between drama and comedy. The image is perfectly sharp, and I, for one, was certainly untroubled by edge enhancement.
The features aren’t copious, but they are solid. “Inside The Apartment” is a documentary that keeps director Billy Wilder as the protagonist. Lemmon is, of course, the spotlit subject of “Magic Time: The Art of Jack Lemmon” (the title, incidentally, is a line from The Days of Wine and Roses). Commentary is provided by film producer/historian Bruce Block, who, in a clear, articulate fashion, tackles the movie in minute and painstaking detail.
Even a re-release of film this good is welcome. And this is very welcome.