“There are dark spirits, old and full of hate…The world is in great danger.”
A trilogy is a hard animal to pull off. Even when you have a popular franchise, it is extremely difficult. All of the pieces have to work just right, or you could have a disaster on your hands. It is even harder when you’ve already beaten the odds once and delivered a trilogy that is both loved and a huge box office success. You run into an almost insurmountable mountain of expectations. Your pieces must somehow fit together so that they can be viewed as one whole product. They also need to match the world and production style of the previous trilogy even though technology has changed quite a bit in the decade that separates the two. Lightning doesn’t often strike the same place twice, unless you happen to live in Florida, or, apparently, New Zealand, where Peter Jackson has managed to do the impossible…so far.
It was bad enough that we had to wait a decade for Jackson and company to finally work out all of the lawsuits and issues that kept anyone from making The Hobbit. We learned that the book would be divided into two films, and Peter Jackson would once again be behind the camera. New Zealand would again double for mythical Middle Earth, and all was right in the universe. By Christmas of 2013 we would have the complete story. Well… Christmas 2013 is the ghost of Christmas past, but as we all learned soon before the release of the first, the book has been broken into three films, but they weren’t going to make us wait quite so long for the third and final chapter. It’ll all be over next summer. Except that now it won’t be, and we’re going to have to wait until this Christmas for that final installment. I’m not sure if I can decide if Peter Santa Claus Jackson has been naughty or nice playing all of these waiting games with us. After my viewing of The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug, I’m inclined to lean toward nice. Some things… perhaps….are worth waiting for, after all.
The middle film in a trilogy has the hardest job yet. You’ve already been introduced to the story and its characters, but the film must continue that momentum with the added disadvantage of not being able to deliver a satisfying conclusion. And like Han Solo being frozen in carbonite, you will leave The Desolation Of Smaug inspired, entertained, thrilled and unsatisfied. That’s where that whole waiting a year thing comes in.
When I say the film will leave you unsatisfied, I’m talking about the conclusion, or rather the lack of one. But up until that moment there is plenty to feel good about here.
The story picks up shortly after the first film ended. The opening scene is actually a shot of Peter Jackson himself walking across the screen munching on a carrot. The fellowship of dwarves along with their burglar Bilbo (Freeman) and wizard Gandalf the Grey (McKellen) are now close to the Lonely Mountain. It’s there that the Dwarves had been run out of their kingdom by the dragon Smaug. The journey takes them through Mirkwood Forest, where they encounter the giant spiders who have become emboldened by a growing dark force. The fellowship is the captured by the elfish King Thranduil (Pace) We’ve seen his son before. It’s Legolas (Bloom) and new face Tauriel played by Lost’s Evangeline Lily.
Meanwhile Gandalf has gone to check on Radagast’s (McCoy) story of the necromancer at Dol Guldur. There he encounters the true evil that will play out more significantly in the Lord Of The Rings trilogy, to be sure.
The movie finishes with a rather lengthy climax that pits Bilbo finally against the dragon Smaug with the distinctive voice of Benedict Cumberbatch. This is the scene you were waiting for much as you were Bilbo’s encounter with Gollum in last year’s film. The scene has many of those same elements. Like Gollum, Smaug is toying with Bilbo. There’s even an element of riddle to be solved. The set and production design here is one of the trilogy’s most impressive. Smaug is certainly one of the more imposing and memorable unreal characters in the franchise. While I won’t give up Gollum’s number one spot just yet, I was surprised at how long this encounter could keep me enthralled. There is very little cutaway. There are a couple of intercut moments of the Dwarves getting restless before they finally come to the rescue, and there is a group of segments taken from the perspective of the city that Smaug will target when this is all over. Jackson does a pretty sweet job of building the tension there. Fans of Sherlock have to get a kick out of Holmes and Watson together again in such an epic encounter. Even though Benedict is just delivering the voice, it adds tremendous power and authority to the dragon. Without him it is merely an imaginary creature on a computer screen, as grand as he is. It’s obvious the two have comfortable chemistry, and it was a brilliant choice by Jackson, one that pays off huge dividends for us in the audience.
This film is not as light as the first. The closest to levity comes in the by now famous scene that has the fellowship escaping the elves in barrels on a rolling stream. It’s a tense scene to be sure, but there’s an element of frolicking to be had. I expect to see this ride open at a local Florida amusement park any time now. I’m in.
That’s the primary difference between these films. The Desolation Of Smaug appears to drive a bit more steady. The team find themselves rather quickly from one situation to the next. There isn’t so much of the quiet evening pondering that was a huge part of the first film’s atmosphere. The pace is far more quick until we get to the Smaug confrontation.
Once again Jackson has managed to find even more New Zealand locations that we hadn’t seen yet in almost 12 hours of film to date. The views continue to be breathtaking. Of course there’s plenty of computer magic to tweak these vistas, but much of it is real, and that brings the important element of reality to a film that is at times overburdened by the massive computer-generated effects. There are times that Jackson gives us too much visual, and it can be quite overwhelming. Most of the bad guys we face are computer characters, from the incredibly creepy spiders to the grandeur of Smaug.
Fortunately, Jackson never lets this massive production get in the way of the fact that this is a story of characters, one hero in particular. Martin Freeman and his co-stars deliver the humanity that could have so easily been lost in all of this spectacle. Jackson delivers so many wonderful character moments that we can, for just a moment, forget the big picture and live in Bilbo’s emotions. He’s emerging as a hero, and we see him struggle with the pull of the ring. We have the benefit of knowing just how consuming that pull will eventually be, but it’s so rewarding to see those blossoming early moments as the ring begins to demand its price. As Bilbo finally faces his moment of truth, he is not the same hobbit he was when he left the shire. We see Gandalf’s prediction that he will never be the same come into its own. Again, the interplay between Bilbo and Smaug alone is worth the price of admission to this film.
Evangeline Lily is a welcome new face. She delivers a better performance here than she ever did on Lost. There is strength in this character that I never found in Kate. Fans were obviously delighted at our screening to see Orlando Bloom return. One of my favorite scenes shows his prejudice toward dwarves and cleverly sets up the friendship and rivalry he would share with Gimli in the Lords trilogy. It’s quite nice to see Jackson take just a moment to pay those kinds of things off for the fans. It shows a level of care and a meticulous attention to detail.
This is certainly a disc worth having. You should be warned that there is a bit of a caveat. Christmas will see more than just the release of the final film in this trilogy in theaters. It will also see the release of an extended version of Smaug. It will likely have a continuation of the Appendices. It’s a serious question that bears answering before you put your money down.
The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is presented in its original aspect ratio of 2.40:1. The 1080p image is arrived at with an AVC MPEG-4 codec at an average 25-30 mbps. For some reason Warner Brothers did not provide us with the 3D version of the film, so there is some disappointment. Still, once again there is great beauty in this high-definition image presentation. Textures stand out in every frame. The same care that went into every little detail in production is put on showcase for your viewing pleasure at home. This is likely one of those films that was made to showcase the upcoming 4K home releases. It’s hard for me to imagine a home image much better than this. Black levels are the deepest and truest representations you’ll find…once again. This is truly a show-off piece for your equipment. Lucky me, I am also in the process of putting Oppo’s BD-103 DARBEE edition through its paces. High end equipment like that is what films like this were made for.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 is just as much a show-off for your system. Jackson has created a sound field that truly wraps you in a 360-degree environment. The result is an extraordinary feeling of placement and an immersive experience unlike any film I’ve reviewed on home video in any format. This was not Shore’s best film, but it still sounds glorious here. Dialog is always clear and placed exactly where you expect it. The surrounds complete the effect with their often thrilling boldness. The spider sequences offer some of the best use of surrounds. When Bilbo uses the ring he can understand their language and it envelopes him … and us … in a dizzying display of the unmistakable voice of Gollum himself, Andy Serkis.
Peter Jackson Invites You To The Set: (40:36) This two-part feature provides us with a typical 24 hours on the production. It’s a compilation from many days but represents what went on and when. This was a 24-hour active set with crews working overnight to prep for the following day.
Music Video – I See Fire: (5:41)
Live Event – In The Cutting Room: (37:52) On March 25th, 2013 Jackson hosted a live streaming event where fans could ask questions via YouTube or Twitter. He also takes us on a brief tour of the production offices. A few surprise guests join via video feed as well.
Production Videos: (36:48) These are the production Vlogs that Jackson posted in 2013.
Forget about the grand design for two and a half hours. There will be plenty of time to appreciate and take it all in. There will be plenty of critics who will demean the film as just another indulgent romp for the fan boys. They’ve obviously never read Tolkien. Jackson continues to deliver an emotional story that contains more magic than all of the WETA animators can provide. “It never ceases to amaze me, the courage of hobbits.”